NCAA08 vs. AP 2K8 ??

[MiddleFingaz]

EA / 2K and whos better aside... which is the better of the 2 games ?? I bought NCAA but was wondering how 2K8 was...

For those who've played them both, what are the pros and cons of both

:D

[masterkiller33]

If you go deep enough in the threads you will find a couple of people that bought both. They liked All Pro better and if you had it you would to.

[soonersam]

Gameplay is better IMO on 2k, smoother, more fun etc. NCAA has more bells and whistles with dynasty and campus legend. I give 2k an edge on gameplay alone because it is one of the more fun games I've played. I still like NCAA because I'm a big college fan but 2k is growing on me.

[dipietro25]

All of have to say is that 2K has the best animation in a football game ever. EA still has not mastered this. EA has their great cut scene graphics but in terms of in play animation its no comparison. I have both and am contemplating trading NCAA 08 its not bad but not that good either.

[REDSFAN2004]

another thread to be locked.

[The Don 301]

i bought both games and i think they are pretty much even im really liken the online for 2k and the campus legend on ncaa.

[Strictly Business]

NCAA's gameplay is of poor quality due to catch up AI so APF is better but at least NCAA fits on my screen.

[Bwag505]

yeah 2k says they look at how football is actually played and then put it into there game... but i am honestly starting to think they have NEVER seen how people get tackled in real football... cause i will tell you, it is very rare that you can just be Knocked down.... and in madden/ncaa.... there is MAYBE 1 wrap up tackle......

[anESPNfan]

2k8 = great animations, sim play, X's and O's
NCAA08 = Great graphics..and great graphics. The campus mode stuff is kinda cool