Dunking...

[Anthoine]

I think for 2k8 to really take it to the next level you need to seperate the types of dunkers in this game. Shaq pulling off a windmill in the middle of a game is utterly unrealastic. people like vince carter Kobe josh smith etc mostly the highflyers you see dunk should have there own signature dunks and should be diffrent compared to people like Dooling the fact thart you make it so easy for players like dooling and others to pull off 360 pumps is unrealiastic i understand the excitment some people get out of it but i think if he is able to do that in a game shouldnt vince carter be able to pull off a 360 windmill in a game?????

another thing is i disagree with the fact that some people in this game cant dunk wen they do it in real life i understand height may be an issue with someplayers but thats inconsiderate of the fact that they can stull dunk. An EXAMPLE of this can be T.J FORD in comparson to NATE ROBINSON although nate robinson was in the dunk contest if you look at the 06-07 season T.J ford dunks twice as many times DURING GAMEPLAY then nate robinson yet t.j ford only has a 57 dunks rating. i understand the fact that nate robinson has ups but if someone is dunking more consistantly then he then shouldnt they have the right to at least HAVE A RATING WHERE THEY CAN DUNK A BALL?????? witch in this case would be 65 atleast

[VirusSnake]

the thing is that dooling and ford SHOULD NOT be able to dunk all the times...they should go for fingerolls 95% of the time.and dunk it rarely over defenders and fastbreaks!


they should decrease the dunking frequency in the game...u can easily take nate or smush or even marbury and start dunkin on shaq or ben that bull******...

[VirusSnake]

noone replys to the thread cuz everybody wants to dunk and get dunked on like 100 times a game...

[kb24lalaland]

I think for 2k8 to really take it to the next level you need to seperate the types of dunkers in this game. Shaq pulling off a windmill in the middle of a game is utterly unrealastic. people like vince carter Kobe josh smith etc mostly the highflyers you see dunk should have there own signature dunks and should be diffrent compared to people like Dooling the fact thart you make it so easy for players like dooling and others to pull off 360 pumps is unrealiastic i understand the excitment some people get out of it but i think if he is able to do that in a game shouldnt vince carter be able to pull off a 360 windmill in a game?????

another thing is i disagree with the fact that some people in this game cant dunk wen they do it in real life i understand height may be an issue with someplayers but thats inconsiderate of the fact that they can stull dunk. An EXAMPLE of this can be T.J FORD in comparson to NATE ROBINSON although nate robinson was in the dunk contest if you look at the 06-07 season T.J ford dunks twice as many times DURING GAMEPLAY then nate robinson yet t.j ford only has a 57 dunks rating. i understand the fact that nate robinson has ups but if someone is dunking more consistantly then he then shouldnt they have the right to at least HAVE A RATING WHERE THEY CAN DUNK A BALL?????? witch in this case would be 65 atleast

i totally agree with you that there should be differnt catagories

[eye guy]

Yeah I agree, when I see Shaq doing a windmill, it get annoying...

[onez88888888]

Yeah, there should be something like this:
0-50: can't dunk
50-60: can dunk, but only easy ones (simple two/onehander)
60-70: can do maybe a reverse or something
70-80: can do things like 360s, windmills, etc.
80-90: can do things like a reverse windmill, etc.
90-100: can do the most fancy dunks in tha game

[xxxDrayxxx]

Lol Iverson was dunking on me online.

[Lord Arklon]

My thing is my role player or bench PF and C that absolutely refuse to dunk. Ridiculous that I can have a 6'11 player that will go for a layup(and miss of course) instead oif attempting a dunk. All because he's not the best dunker and has a dunk rating in the 60s, shouldn't mean jack. There should be several separate ratings, i.e. Dunk Tendency, Dunk Strength, Dunk Success In Traffic, and finally Dunk Package.

[illsmak]

They need two stats. Something to do with hops and something to do with creativity, maybe even a 3rd one to do with power.

So if people can hop above the rim and have the power to throw it down on someone, then they will, but unless it's the all star game and Shaq is dcking around he's never gonna do anything but a one or two handed dunk.

They totally need to revamp the dunking because it's horrible. The amount of people in the NBA that can dunk on people are very few, and those guys get 99 in dunks. lol. No one gets a 99 in dunks, I mean come on. That's like having a 99 in 3 pointers and making every shot no matter what.

People attack the basket a lot and that's cool, but they rarely should end up in a dunk. They need more collision detection and something to do with foot planting and the trajectory of your attack... because if you get like 3 steps towards the rim straight towards it, you should be able to dunk on just about anyone with a decent jumper.

Plus, footwork has a lot to do with dunking. People have to be able to plant their feet well to get a good jump. People like Amare would be sick at that.

-Smak

[Decyrus]

how about a "dunk in traffic" rating system? guys with a low rating are least likely to dunk on the heads of shaq like players... also at a fancy dunk rating system for those players like vince carter and kobe bryant.

[illsmak]

The more rating categories the better (unless it's Live. heh) because it's hard to have one category define someone's dunking, shooting, blocking or stealing. There are so many different aspects, that's why they need more athletic categories like side to side movement, footwork... etc.

Until they implement that well, the game will always be glitched out a little bit.

-Smak