Guess the ratings for MLB 2K9!

[derekjeter76]

Ok, here it is how it works. I say a players name and then the next guy posts what they think his rating in MLB 2K9 will be and posts a new name. Then the next poster says what they think.

Remember: MLB 2K does ratings based off of the past 3 years, so a good/bad last year may not affect a guy too much if he has been in the league a long time.

ok, let's start.

Joba Chamberlain

[jna1270712]

Joba Chamberlain: 83

[NTG]

the ratings have been really off the past couple of years....they should go to grade system or something...

anyway
Joba 87


CC Sabathia

[Gamerdrw]

well i am guessing since in 2k8 Johan Santana was rated at a 99 i would say CC Sabathia would probably be anywhere from a 97-99 espically after how good he was for the Brewers.....and his stamina will be very good in the game because of how many innings and complete games he pitched

[Draven]

Gamerdrw, make a new player after you answer.

Derek Jeter

[derekjeter76]

Derek Jeter - 89

Manny Ramirez?

[Draven]

Manny Ramirez - 94

Albert Pujols

[wookie2815]

Pujols-99
BJ upton?

[Draven]

89.

David Ortiz

[soldaderyan]

David Ortiz- 89

Robie Cano:

[NTG]

Cano: 84


David Price

[Draven]

83.

Juan Pierre

[luke_51034]

Pierre: 70

Ryan Dempster

[derekjeter76]

Dempster: 82

Justin Verlander?

[KOOL2K7]

84. am pretty close

[Draven]

KOOL2k7, make a player to be answered.

Chris Carpenter

[chad0034]

Chris Carpenter- 86-88

Prince Fielder:

p.s. eventually this winter ill come out w/ my typical top 20 in each position and post them here. they are basically my ratings i will use for MLB 2K9.. i make all the moves myself etc. its fun to do imo. and i like hearing what people think about them so i post them here.

[Draven]

Prince Fielder - 88-90

Aramis Ramirez

[chad0034]

87-89

Ryan Braun?.. i think Fielder will be in the 90's too.. at least he will be in my rosters..probly a 92-93, and i really hope they put in their player pics this year.. that was soo horrible last year to look at those.

[FrenziedSokar]

Braun will be in the early 90's i would say 92

Brad Lidge

[Draven]

91-93.

Miguel Tejada

[luke_51034]

Tejada: 87

Cliff Lee

[NTG]

even thogh he won the cy young I still dont think he's all that good
89

ryan howard

[FrenziedSokar]

he will likely be around the early 90's again..92-93


Carlos Pena

[luke_51034]

Pena: 88

Geovany Soto

[chad0034]

86.. he deserves it..
Rich Harden?

[the catch 85]

95? more like 80-85

[chad0034]

that was my bad.. i was on the other page.. that was for Brad Lidge..i edited it.. he should get at least an 84 im guessing.
Rich Harden?

[the catch 85]

90 i guess

[the catch 85]

carlos delgado

[derekjeter76]

Carlos Delgado: 86

Dustin Pedroia?

[SFG MLB]

86

Dustin Pedroia?

88

Tim Lincecum?

[JH 293]

Lincecum- 93-96

Evan Longoria?

[SFG MLB]

Lincecum- 93-96

Evan Longoria?
88

Pablo Sandoval?

[Draven]

85-87

Victor Martinez

[bxitalian]

Victor Martinez 85

Hanley Remirez

[Draven]

92-94.

Ivan Rodriguez

[luke_51034]

Ivan Rodriguez: 82

Ryan Ludwick

[Draven]

85.

Alfonso Soriano

[chad0034]

Soriano 91
Neifi Perez ?

[derekjeter76]

lol, Neifi Perez: 68

A.J. Burnett?

[SFG MLB]

lol, Neifi Perez: 68

A.J. Burnett?

89

Fred Lewis?

[bxitalian]

89

Fred Lewis?


82

mo rivera

[derekjeter76]

82

mo rivera

92

Jason Isringhausen?

[SFG MLB]

92

Jason Isringhausen?
He had a bad season and should retire, didn't he do that once already?

77


Jon Lester?

[wookie2815]

Lester - 88 maybe 89

Josh Hamiltion

[Draven]

92.

Francisco Rodriguez

[SFG MLB]

Lester - 88 maybe 89

Josh Hamiltion

90 and climbing

Orlando Hudson?

[Draven]

84.

Tony Clark(1B, Arizona)

[luke_51034]

Clark: 71

Jay Bruce

[derekjeter76]

Jay Bruce

80.

Curt Schilling?

[krunchybox]

85

C.C. Sabathia

[krunchybox]

94

Carl Crawford

[chad0034]

Crawford: 90

Edinson Volquez?

[SFG MLB]

Crawford: 90

Edinson Volquez?
87
Jason Bay?

[chad0034]

Jason Bay: 86-88 he did well in boston

Russell Martin?

[jna1270712]

82.

Pelfrey (Mets)?
and
Griffey Jr.?
and
Johnny Cueto?
and
Adam Dunn? lol sorry for so many at one time lol

[Gamerdrw]

Pelfrey: probably in the mid 80's he improved a lot espically after him being rate a 69 in 2K8....i would say 83-86..he won some very important games for the Mets and pitched back-to-back complete games

Griffey Jr.:...he is getting old.. lower 80's upper 70's: 79-84

Johnny Ceuto: had to go look him up...with the stats Games Won: 9 Games Lost:14 ERA: 4.81...I would probably say 78..he is young though...so his ratings will probably be better in future games if he does not become a bust in the majors.

Adam Dunn: he is getting slow in the outfield...stricking out a lot and and his BA was kinda low this year..i would say 79 or 80 MAYBE 82

How about Luis Castillo?

[chad0034]

Russell Martin 82? I think he'll be at least a 85-86...
and Adam Dunn will be over 79.. i guarntee that.. he'll be upper 80s most likely.. like an 88
Luis Castillo: 77

Chase Utley?
Aramis Ramirez?

[SFG MLB]

Russell Martin 82? I think he'll be at least a 85-86...
and Adam Dunn will be over 79.. i guarntee that.. he'll be upper 80s most likely.. like an 88
Luis Castillo: 77

Chase Utley?
Aramis Ramirez?

92
90

Matt Cain (http://sanfrancisco.giants.mlb.com/team/player.jsp?player_id=430912)?

[GSW believer]

84

matt holiday

[Abyss Impact]

90-93

Brian Wilson?

[SFG MLB]

90-93

Brian Wilson?
He got allot of saves but gives up allot of runs so 79.

Milton Bradley?

[chad0034]

Milton Bradley-85

Dontrelle Willis?
Ryan Theriot?

[SFG MLB]

Milton Bradley-85

Dontrelle Willis?
Ryan Theriot?

2 crap seasons puts Willis at a 74 to 76

Theriot 81


Magglio Ordonez (http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/profile?playerId=3728)?

[Draven]

87-90

Rafael Furcal

[kingblue18]

87-90

Rafael Furcal

Hurt so much, Furcal is falling, I'd say 83.

Geovany Soto?

[Draven]

81-83.

Jimmy Rollins

[Complex Realmz]

Rollins = 87

Zack Greinke?

[SFG MLB]

Rollins = 87

Zack Greinke?

78

Vladimir Guerrero?

[Draven]

88.

Justin Verlander

[wookie2815]

guerrero- 88 (had a so and so past 2 seasons)

Jason Werth- Keep in mind that hes philly's man nxt year AND he is a stud.


FOR SFGMLB only:

Figured this would make you smile. Rate the following:

Angel Villalone
Emmanuel Burris
Nate Schierholtz
Tim Alderson
Kevin Pucetas
Madison Bumgarner

[wookie2815]

Sorry draven, didnt see your post...85 verlander

Now read my above post

[Draven]

Werth - 87.

Jack Wilson

[SFG MLB]

guerrero- 88 (had a so and so past 2 seasons)

Jason Werth- Keep in mind that hes philly's man nxt year AND he is a stud.


FOR SFGMLB only:

Figured this would make you smile. Rate the following:

Angel Villalone
Emmanuel Burris
Nate Schierholtz
Tim Alderson
Kevin Pucetas
Madison Bumgarner

Angel Villalone 65
Emmanuel Burris 74
Nate Schierholtz 73
Tim Alderson 67
Kevin Pucetas 69
Madison Bumgarner 68

Jack Wilson 79

Justin Duchscherer?

[luke_51034]

Justin Duchscherer: 82-84

Kosuke ***udome?
Jeff Samardzija?
Mark DeRosa?

[Complex Realmz]

***odome - 70
Samardzija - 65
DeRosa = 77

Coco Crisp?
Mike Aviles?
Joakim Soria?

[Draven]

Crisp - 80-82
Aviles - 73-75
Soria - 77-79

Milton Bradley

[SFG MLB]

Crisp - 80-82
Aviles - 73-75
Soria - 77-79

Milton Bradley

Bradley was done already!

[Draven]

Bradley was done already!Then:
Justin Morneau...

[derekjeter76]

It doesn't matter if someone was done yet or not because who really wants to search through all those pages and look at every name?

Anyways, Mornean = 92

David Ortiz?

[Complex Realmz]

Papi - 91

Dan Uggla?

[Draven]

It doesn't matter if someone was done yet or not because who really wants to search through all those pages and look at every name?

Anyways, Mornean = 92

David Ortiz?Exactly.

Papi - 91

Dan Uggla?91-94.
Adrián González

[Frek21]

82-85

Chipper Jones

[Draven]

90-93.

Andrew Jones

[chad0034]

Andruw Jones- 73-75

Jimmy Rollins?

[Kroginator]

Jimmy Rollins 84-86 .....

A.J Burnett?

[tbone1018]

AJ Burnett 86-89

Carlos Quentin? Would've been MVP if he stayed healthy

[Draven]

91-93.

Cliff Lee

[derekjeter76]

Lee: 87

Jason Varitek?

[Draven]

Varitek: 84.

Jonathan Johnston

[Abyss Impact]

JJ- 82

God?

[chad0034]

god: 100

JJ Hardy?

[tcg64712]

God?

Dustin Pedroia - 94

JJ Hardy?

Hardy - 85

Jacoby Ellsbury?
Kevin Youkilis?

[otto221]

72
jose reyes??????????

[Alai]

reyes: 84

felix hernandez

[sappy3]

Hernandez: 86

Matt Kemp?
Andre Ethier?
Chad Billingsley?
Clayton Kershaw?


sorry :)

[Draven]

Kemp - 88

Jonothan Broxton

[chad0034]

Ahh Kemp won't be an 88 .. im positive.. he'll be around a 80- to the mid 80s. I wouldn't be surprised if 2K put him in the 70s... 2K always underestimate young players (see: Geovany Soto) and overestimate the old (see: Mike Sweeney)
Jon Broxton: 83
Matt Kemp: 84
Andre Ethier: 82
Chad Billingsley: 84
Clayton Kershaw: 75

Ted Lilly?

[ronkon29]

84

Daiskue Matsusaka

[derekjeter76]

84

Daiskue Matsusaka

89

and lol at the guy who said Pedroia was a 94 (he won't even be a 90) and for stating his numbers when someone said God.

[Abyss Impact]

Barry Bonds?

[chad0034]

he won't be in the game. but if he was i'd say 76

Khalil Greene?

[biggestcubsfan]

khail greene 77

Pat Burrel

[bigmanc]

pat burrel

80

brandon webb

[billyd08096]

Shane Victorino?

[billyd08096]

brandon webb: 95

Shane Victorino

[chad0034]

Victorino- 83

Brandon Phillips?

[kingblue18]

Brandon Phillips- 86

carlos zambrano?

[THE BIZZ 510]

zambrano 85

cole hamels ?

[alexmm0555]

zambrano 85

cole hamels ?

Cole Hamels 86

Jorge Cantu
Carlos Quentin
Nomar Garciaparra?

[luke_51034]

Cantu: 80
Quentin: 88
Garciapara: 72

Carlos Marmol?
Brad Lidge?

[chad0034]

Marmol- 84
Lidge- 94

CC Sabathia?

[derekjeter76]

92

Magglio Ordonez?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

Magglio 88

Ryan Theriot?

[omgzgabe12]

Theriot: 84
Barry Zito?

[dubbz09]

Zito:81

Mark Teixiera

[RedsFan#1932]

Teixera 90

Willy Tavares
Arthur Rhodes
Homer Bailey
Micah Owings
Xavier Nady

[Tbreen1212]

84

Mark Texeira?

[derekjeter76]

92

Garret Atkins?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

85

mike fontenot

[RedsFan#1932]

Fontenot 73

Willy Tavares?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

75

Mike Fontenot

[chad0034]

haha Fontenot 77

Albert Pujols

[RKO BLACK RKO]

thank you chad lol

99

Kevin Gregg

[chuito2k]

robie cano-86

[chad0034]

random? You didn't even answer the player...

Kevin Gregg- 79-80

Barry Bonds ? If he returns.

[chuito2k]

do u think if i take the following games to gamestop they will buy them? and how much will they give me?

system:xbox360

1.nba 2k7
2.mlb 2k7
3.fifa 07

[RKO BLACK RKO]

do u think if i take the following games to gamestop they will buy them? and how much will they give me?

system:xbox360

1.nba 2k7
2.mlb 2k7
3.fifa 07

please read the title of the thread and understand the concept b4 you post this not the place to ask questions thanx

[chuito2k]

barry bonds shouldnt be rated or be in the game yet until he completes 2 weeks in mlb so it can be a more reasonable rate

[chuito2k]

can someone just answer and i will keep rating

[RKO BLACK RKO]

wow hhmm barry bonds 81 just off of name value

cover boy tim lincecum
barry zito
matt cain

[chuito2k]

chase utley-91

pedro alvarez(if makes it to the big this season)-?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

barry bonds shouldnt be rated or be in the game yet until he completes 2 weeks in mlb so it can be a more reasonable rate

again explinations arent needed just rate a player ask a player rate a player ask a player thats the concept thanx :thumbsup:

[Diddles]

pedro alvarez 77

Travis Snyder ?
Matt Garza?
Adam Lind?

[chuito2k]

fgiagdsgdanihshfdbdadgd

[chuito2k]

matt garza-87

yunel escobar?

[chad0034]

chase utley-91

pedro alvarez(if makes it to the big this season)-?

whyd this dude randomly say Chase Utley? I dont think anyone asked for him.

[chad0034]

do u think if i take the following games to gamestop they will buy them? and how much will they give me?

system:xbox360

1.nba 2k7
2.mlb 2k7
3.fifa 07

:confused: In all my time here on the 2K Forums, I dont think i've met a more random person than this guy. Check out his awesome all-star team thread. and for all that, you won't get over 250...im guessing.

[chuito2k]

chad your really on my **** .. i think u like me u some *** type a ****.. chase utley was on the page befor this so stop riding my nutzzzzzzz and i told u be4 it was a all star team of my fav. players and ******* the system wasnt included it was just the 3 things i mention on the listen if i was selling the system to it would of had a number next to it and u say i am uneducated man SUCK THESSEEEE

[RKO BLACK RKO]

chad your really on my **** .. i think u like me u some *** type a ****.. chase utley was on the page befor this so stop riding my nutzzzzzzz and i told u be4 it was a all star team of my fav. players and ******* the system wasnt included it was just the 3 things i mention on the listen if i was selling the system to it would of had a number next to it and u say i am uneducated man SUCK THESSEEEE


ahem well like you said your kid so i dont expect you to respond like an adult or even have a discussion like and adult. But please don't muddy up the forums with your insults. if you wanna talk baseball or this game sure but that's it and b4 you try to bust out a lame insult direct your attention here

2k sports commitee please listen to me.

i am a young kid and i looooooove baseball and i also play baseball. one thing i always make sure of before every game is that i am stylish.You 2k people really need to get contracts with nike,mizuno,vedero,jordan,and rawlings and etc. to put some more excitement in creating a player and editing players i believe your sales will go up just for sumthing as simple as that. and the game will be more fun then what it originally is.mainly the 2k companied thing is getting kind of old, put some spice into it.(dont get me wrong i enjoy your games ) but work harder on the graphix for 360 and gameplay and and try to work something out with companies like nike, jordan, rawlings etc..


hope you take in to consideration

thank u
chuito2k.

[RedsFan#1932]

Escobar 81

Rocco Baldelli?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

Rocco Baldelli 85

Big Papi?

[robin10822]

Lol there's no way Jose Reyes will be rated an 84 try 94, anyway......

Papi-92

Carlos Beltran, Ryan Church, Daniel Murphy? (sorry for 3 people)

[h3adshot66612]

beltran 92
church 82
murphy 74 (to be honest murphy is just a rookie i'll be suprised if he plays in major league)
wang?
nady?
alex rios?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

wang 91
nady 82
alex rios 79

Joakim Soria? (note: hes prob the closer im going to be going after in all of our mlb 2k9 fantasy drafts)

[soldaderyan]

Soria: 90

Brett Gardner ?
Andrew Jones ?

[Spyre112]

Brett Gardner: 77-82
Andruw Jones: 84: He had a horrendous year but he's had solid numbers in the past...

[Spyre112]

Roy Halladay, Vladdy, and Travis Snider, K-rod
Sorry if any of these guys were mentioned previously

[chad0034]

Roy Halladay, Vladdy, and Travis Snider, K-rod
Sorry if any of these guys were mentioned previously
Halladay- 94-95 (Look at the CG)
Vlad Guerrero- 91-93 (getting older)
Travis Snyder- 77
K-Rod-97 (one of the best in the game, but overrated)

[Spyre112]

Carl Pavano? XD
A.J. Burnett?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

carl pavano - 79

A.J. Burnett - 87 but doesnt deserve it hes gonna be higher rated cause hes on the yanks now

Kevin Youkilis

[Marin3rs]

Youk 86

evan Longoria
Brandon morrow

[RKO BLACK RKO]

evan longoria - 88

brandon morrow - 77

E. Vólquez?
J. Votto?
J. Cueto?

[Spyre112]

Volquez: 88
Votto: 84
Cueto: 81

Giambi?
Matsui?
Jered Weaver?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

Giambi 82
Matsui 84
Jered Weaver 76 but i might be thinking of the wrong weaver

john smoltz?
dustin pedroria?

[soldaderyan]

Jered Weaver 83, I think RKO was thinking in jeff weaver

smoltz: 81
D.pedroia : 90

Randy jonhson ?

[biggestcubsfan]

82
Jeff samardgzia

[Tmoney8]

75

Brian McCann?
Kenshin Kawakami?
Jeff Francoeur?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

Brian McCann 84
Kenshin Kawakami they never give japanese players there due on launch so 78
Jeff Francoeur 86

henry blanco
daryll ward
Micah Hoffpauir

[RedsFan#1932]

Blanco 71
Ward 75
Hoffpauir 69

Jay Bruce?
Arthur Rhodes?
Jonny Gomes?

[Tmoney8]

Jay Bruce- 77
Arthur Rhodes-80
Jonny Gomes-63 ( he didn'y play but like 70 gms and he hit .182)

Derek Lowe?
Jair Jurrjens?
Kelly Johnson?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

Derek Lowe - 82
Jair Jurrjens -80
Kelly Johnson - 78

Micah Hoffpauir

Aaron Rowand

[Pujols4MVP12]

Rowand - 80 or 81
Hoffpauir - 72

How about: Yadier Molina? Rick Ankiel? Adam Wainwright?

[h3adshot66612]

yadier 75
rick 80-83
adam83-85
bj upton ?
ben sheets ?
andy (cry baby) pettite yes im a yankee fan

[Tmoney8]

Come on man a 80 for jj, he had a 3.68 era 13-10 he gotta be mid to high 80's.....i hope so lol

BJ Upton-78
Ben Sheets-88

Stephen Drew?
JD Drew?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

imma stephen drew fan boy ( hes in the group of certain players i like) so im not gonna answer that 1

JD Drew - 84

Kevin Greg
Kevin Greg's Glasses lol
Chad Gaudin

[Tmoney8]

[QUOTE=RKO BLACK RKO;2196459]imma stephen drew fan boy ( hes in the group of certain players i like) so im not gonna answer that 1

haha me too...i'm from valdosta,Ga and went to the same school (LHS) that all 3 Drew bros. went to so i'm a big fan of stephen and jd too....

Kevin Greg's Glasses lol---94

[RKO BLACK RKO]

well your town won espn's award for i forgot what it was but you all blew away the field lol and exactly what i was thinking about, those are some fine glasses lol

[Tmoney8]

yea titletown...

Troy Tulowitzki?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

Troy Tulowitzki 87

Rocky Cherry

[Tmoney8]

Rocky Cherry- 72

Carl Crawford?
Dioner Navarro?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

Carl Crawford 88 speed 98
Dioner Navarro 79

A-rod
Dice-K

[RKO BLACK RKO]

amd im suprised that somebody besides me, chad or eric knew who rocky cherry was lol

[DurantPwnsYou]

Arod 98
Dice K 93

(Didn't read any pages so don't know if this guy was said yet or not but..)

Jed Lowrie?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

Jed Lowrie 67

matt damon

[Tmoney8]

while we wait...

matt damon lol-34

Dan Uggla?
Scott Olsen?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

dan uggla 84

scott olsen 77

and it doesnt look like we are getting any info anytime soon today so migh as well do this

andy pet.

oliver perez

[Tmoney8]

haha true...

andy p.-82
oliver perez-86

Ryan Zimmerman?
Justin Upton?

[RKO BLACK RKO]

ryan zimmerman 80

justin upton 81

jay feely

[kingblue18]

ryan zimmerman 80

justin upton 81

jay feely

A.) Doesn't he kick for the Giants? The FOOTBALL team, lets keep this to baseball.

B.) I know who Rocky Cherry is.

C.) Andrew Jones

[MetsFan075]

Andruw Jones-79

Jose Reyes

[Blind synergy]

Jose Reyes - 88

Adam Lind?

[Meekay08]

Adam Lind- 78..if he makes th eroster and starts he could be in th elow 80's

How bout top prospect Matt Weiters?

[MetsFan075]

Matt Wieters- 71

Matt Holliday

[Marin3rs]

holliday-88

ryan rowland-smith
brandon morrow

[Meekay08]

wieters a 71?

[Ohiostatefan0133]

Well it is probably a safe guess that whoever won awards last year but are not big names (ie. Cliff Lee - pictured at left) will not be rated as high as they should be. Those players always get ripped off. I would put Lee (after last years performances) 90-95 but we all know that that won't happen.

[Marin3rs]

they are gonna make a-rod a 100 after such a crappy season compared to the past few

[Meekay08]

i mean they rated jay bruce the number one prospect last year a 80...so i think weiters should be around that rating

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

wieters a 71?

Yes he will start low, Jay Bruce started around 76 I believe until he did something. Your Os bias is making you believe more. He will be 77-80 most likely by the time he starts playing.

Brandon Morrow - 79


John Lannan

[Meekay08]

John Lannan 74

Nick MArkakis

and to go on to matt wieters....ya thats sounds good around 78

[RKO BLACK RKO]

A. king blue i was just kidding

B. LETS KEEP THIS THREAD TO NAMING PLAYERS AND GIVING RESPONSES THATS ALL

C. zack duke

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

Nick Markakis - 86

Zack Duke - 77

Didn't see if posted earlier but another nats player

Cristian Guzman

[Wookie481512]

Christian Guzman- 83 (with good contact ratings)

Josh Hamilton

Nelson Cruz (keep in mind his recent power discovery, he led the minors and broke some records I think)

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

Yea Guzman I think will be an 80 with mad good contact but power a little low, he did very well last year but didnt get to much a good rating after patches i thought,

Josh Hamilton - was an 88... i might say 89 (increase in power stats a bit?)

Nelson Cruz couldnt answer

Mike Jacobs
Nelson Cruz

[mattNY]

mike jacobs 80
nelson cruz 71

mark teixeira

[MetsFan075]

Mark Teixeira- 92

Chone Figgins
Adam Dunn

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

Chone Figgins - 81
Adam Dunn - 84 or 85 again

Mighta been done:

Josh Willingham (just like seein what other people see nats players as lol)

[MetsFan075]

Josh Willingham- 83

Alex Gordon

[AlbertPujolsFreak5]

Gordon = 81 IMO

sorry if its been asked but...
Rick Ankiel
Yadier Molina
Joe Mather
Skip Schumaker
Brett Wallace

sorry for so many at once!

[bleedteelandsilver]

Ankiel-80
Molina-74
Mather-76
Schumaker- 72
Wallace-70
just my opinion

Jorge Cantu
Matt Lindstrom

[Wookie481512]

Josh hamilton an 89! No way!!! Thats an under rating job for a guy who was an RBI machine and a .300 + hitter. Not to mention the starter as an allstar!

Josh Hamiton-95
Nelson- 83 (power) Actual contact and batter vision might be low
Jorge Cantu- 82
Lindstrom-? I dont follow him so I wouldnt know what to rate him.

Heres some good ones:

Matt Garza
Pat Burrell
Dioner Navarro (.300+ hitter who is clutch and was in great shape last season. Maddons Leader)
Rocco Baldelli
Elvis andrus
Michael Young @ 3B
Hank Blalock @ DH (More energy and better health)
Chris Davis
matt LaPorta (Next longoria so be honest)
mark Derosa
and last but certainly not least, the dangerous, and skilled, plus the always powerful stud:

Andruw Jones!!!!

[slantedeyematt]

andrew jones= 72
navarro=85
Pat burrell= 80
Matt garza=85-90 (somewhere there)

[YANKEES DYNASTY]

Derek Jeter
Alex rodriguez
Mark Texeira
CC Sabathia
Chien-Ming Wang
Aj burnett
Andy Pettite
Joba Chamerlain
Robinson Cano

GO YANKEES!

[yankees102412]

DJ: 84
A-Rod: 98
Tex: 94
CC: 96
Wang: 92
AJ: 90
Joba: 89 (Should be 92-93, but wont)
Robby: 86 (Should be lower, but wont drop him that much from last yr)

[yankees102412]

Heres an issue: Do you guys think they will FINALLY add Chamberlain's Photo and signature style?

[Marin3rs]

the yankees are such sore losers. i mean look at that list CC, Aj, Tex, A-rod, Jeter, Joba the first 4 take up over 500 mil altogether showing how desperate they are.

A-rod=92
CC=97
AJ=92
Joba=82
Jeter=89
tex=95
Wang=84

Ichiro
bedard
Lopez
beltre
johjima

[slantedeyematt]

Yea no, this game is a business that is like telling donald trump... "yo stop buying so many properties save some for the other stupid business owners who dont know what there doing" As a fan of a team that is what you want a owner who cares unlike teams like the marlins owner who gives there good players away for chump change just for there pockets. The stienbrenners put all the money they get back to the team.

BTW no way A-rod will be a 92 LOL

Derek Jeter- 88
Alex rodriguez- 98
Mark Texeira- 95
CC Sabathia- 95
Chien-Ming Wang- 92
Aj burnett- 90
Andy Pettite- 86
Joba Chamerlain- 90
Robinson Cano- 85

[slantedeyematt]

Ichiro- 95
bedard- 83
beltre- 90
johjima- 87

[YANKEES DYNASTY]

Ichiro-96
Bedard-81
Beltre-84
johjima-88

Manny Ramirez
David Ortiz
Dustin Pedroia
Josh beckett
kevin Youkalis

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

wow alot of yankees bias here

Derek Jeter- 88
Alex rodriguez- 98
Mark Texeira- 93
CC Sabathia- 95
Chien-Ming Wang- 89
Aj burnett- 87
Andy Pettite- 84
Joba Chamerlain- 86
Robinson Cano- 85

[slantedeyematt]

Yea Aj burnett isnt going to be a 87 and joba isnt going to be a 86 lol.....and 86 is a mediocre rating along with 87 and everyone can agree both are not mediocre pitchers. But like i said it will be hard to have people be mature about it so i wont say no more

[slantedeyematt]

LOL and wang an 89 lol you must hate the yankees lol....considering wang had 8 wins and didnt even pitch a whole first half of a season. I could honestly say wang would of won 20 games if he didnt get hurt. Wang= 92

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

No its just I doubt every player is going to be above an 88 on the yankees.. Sure wang COULDVE had that but he got injured. Theyre not going to compensate what he missed.

[slantedeyematt]

No but they arent going to LOWER his rating because he got hurt either

[joejccva7112]

No but they arent going to LOWER his rating because he got hurt either

Actually they should lower it a little bit because of his injuries. As a player you are not as effective as you were due to playtime, injuries, etc. It's only right that his rating should be lowered. I'm not saying lower it drastically but a few overall points.

It's more realistic bud.

[slantedeyematt]

-_- No not when you have all season to recover ect ect and he wont be missing spring traing either. If anything his rating should be the same "that would be more realistic bud"

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

lol, no it wouldnt dude, if a guy plays some games and does well, fine. If he gets injured, you shouldn't just stay there and then say oh predicting his stats hed have gone this many wins etc for this many games... it doesn't work like that.

It should give him a penalty for how long hes out.

Example: Nick Johnson, a few years ago i think he was an 85 or so... He hasnt played many games since then, has missed about 2 seasons and played in a total of like 50 somethin games for 2 years... his rating went down to an 80 at the start of 2k8 and in 2k9 I wouldnt be surprised if hes a 70 something.

Ming Wang shouldnt be given a handicap because he was injured, they should start him off around 87-89 and then see how he does in ST/Opening month... remember its Living Rosters so dont get your panties in a bunch since its updated every day/week

[joejccva7112]

-_- No not when you have all season to recover ect ect and he wont be missing spring traing either. If anything his rating should be the same "that would be more realistic bud"

You're wrong. By not playing, (in almost every sports game) the ratings drop a little bit. Look at NFL Head Coach which is probably the most realistic sports game to date right now as far as progression and statistics go. If a player was injured for even half the season, by the time he got back on the field his OVR rating was down some. It only makes sense.

Not sure what you're smoking, but I want some ...superbowl is tomorrow. :)

[slantedeyematt]

Look at the diffrence wang pitched great when he was on the mound and got hurt half the season. NOT HIS FAULT. So his rating should have gone down because he was still pitching great before that fyi his rating last year was 89 i belive. He should still be there because any rating lower than that is a scrub number and in no way shape or form is chen ming wang a scrub. You also gotta remember not everyone have access to internet to update there roster (Wii) so they wont put his rating low because they know some people cant update the roster. Therefore his rating will probably stay at around 89-90

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

hahaha to much love for your yankees that your going insane with ratings. anything below an 89 is NOT a scrub rating. You wouldn't know that though cause your owners buy talent and rarely make their own. Sure it might not be "his" fault for getting injured but hes not playing during that time either so giving him a good rating for that time missed is insane.

[Marin3rs]

im sure if you lose someone for atleast 8 weeks or more then there off the team.

[slantedeyematt]

^^^what?

and to falcgun well ifyou say so bud. I would understand if it was just some ordanary player but wang earned a 90 rating what would be the point of bringing him down? either way i couldnt care less what you have to say because your going to say the same dumb thing

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

Sorry if the truth is dumb to you but yes, they will bring ratings down if someones a 90, I know this example is going to be understood but how you said it deserves correcting...

Andruw Jones, yes he blew, but he was about a 90 and went down to an 80... They wont hesitate to move someone down if theyre a 90...

What exactly makes Wang not ordinary?

Now i'm going to name someone to get back on topic because he won't even take another opinion from how stubborn he seems to be acting.

Corey Hart

[slantedeyematt]

Did you just compare andrew jones to chen-ming wang are you retarted. Those are to opposite cases. Wang did not have like and era of 7 (which would be the equivalent of what andrew jones did) Jones played worse than like joey gathright or something you gotta be kidding me right. Jones was so bad its not even funny. What a fool you have to be to compare the too. That statement just official makes you and everyone else who agreed with you lose and now I win because your an idiot

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

how old are you dude? did you not read what I said?

"I know this example is going to be understood but how you said it deserves correcting..."

I meant that for the Andruw Jones statement.. he was horrible yes, but the way you said "Ming Wang isnt an ordinary player and they wont drop his rating down" deserved it... Plus you avoided answering my only question and just spat out the same thing in 3 different sentences with different words.

Way to go you know how to prove a point. /end sarcasm.

Please get off Wangs sack

"Corey Hart"

[slantedeyematt]

Wang was a 90 yes but he got injured so since it is living rosters they will just keep him at 90 and if he blows than he goes down simple as that. Your not going to give a potential ace a lower grade level just because he got injured.

Would you bring down fausto carmona's rating just because he got hurt. The answer is NO, because he is good and because he got hurt. That is a real example unlike the idiotic one you put above

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

Your right there, but I wasn't just saying a minor injury, no he shouldn't lose rating, but he was out for more than 3 quarters of the season.. All Im saying is giving him a rating like that just because he was on a tear in the first month is absurd... Sure he MAY have done that the rest of the year, he MAY not have... it all depends.

I just dont think a player who played for barely the season injury or not should get that high of a rating. Plus I didnt say he was bad at all and Im sure he will get that high anyway if he continues like he pitched in the month of April last year.

[slantedeyematt]

My point is that he pitchd just about half a season. Maybe 2 or so games under, but he should not go up or down h should stay even because he showed no sign of slowing down and should stay at his original rating and shouldnt be put down at all because in the end what stats are you gunna take away from him??? carmona was out for a little less than wang and he should not go down in raitin either so its not like im saying this just because hes a yankee i would be saying this for anyone who didnt have a bad season and got hurt. Tell me what stat are you going to take away from wang or carmona???

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

Injury or Stamina at the least, either way I just think its unfair for a player to have the same rating even though you make a point. Like im a Washington fan for everything, and I think what Gilbert is doing to the wizards is BS even though hes my favorite player. Like hes always going to be a 90 something cause hes a star but I do think they should lower his rating or, like they do, take him out just cause he isnt even playing now and said he might not even play cause the team sucks so bad.

Durability/Stamina/Injury take those down a notch... Again im not saying make him a 68!! I merely said 87-89 lol what is 1-3 points going to do honestly

[x HEAT x]

k-rod ????

[slantedeyematt]

To the gilbert arenas point is, hes hurt every season and hansnt played a full season in idk how long. If you put his durablity down that that would be fine stamina no because stamina dosent have to do with with his injury. how much to do you think you will have to turn durability down to get him down to a 87. It would hve to be like half f his frekin stamina to do that lol (exaggerating) i just dont se it happening

K-rod will be like a 98 or so until his arm falls of lol

[ochonflcinco85]

victor martinez!?
grady sizemore?
travis hafner?
cliff lee?

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

To the gilbert arenas point is, hes hurt every season and hansnt played a full season in idk how long. If you put his durablity down that that would be fine stamina no because stamina dosent have to do with with his injury. how much to do you think you will have to turn durability down to get him down to a 87. It would hve to be like half f his frekin stamina to do that lol (exaggerating) i just dont se it happening

K-rod will be like a 98 or so until his arm falls of lol

It totally makes sense lol, i mean your right putting down his stamina/durability would make him a weakling.

I guess Im also bitter im going to be facing the yankees every damn ranked match.

victor martinez 88
grady sizemore 89
travis hafner 85
cliff lee 91 (imo)

[hemp85]

Nick Markakis
Adam Jones
Brian Roberts

[jmillhimes]

Markakis- 88
Jones- 85
Roberts- 93

Lance Berkman

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

Lance Berkman - 92


Lastings Milledge
Elijah Dukes

[Meekay08]

Lastings Milledge- 81
Eljah Dukes- 77 but with around high 80s power against rightys and leftys

Jeremy Guthrie
Felix Pie
Cesar Izturis
Billy Rowell
Nolan Reimold

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

haha your ratings for milledge and dukes are what I had in my head, hope its true would be pretty mediocre nats team compared to last years low 70s

Jeremy Guthrie -- 86
Felix Pie -- 79
Cesar Izturis -- 79 (good defense, sorta like a vizquel to me)
Billy Rowell -- couldnt answer
Nolan Reimold -- couldnt answer, havent payed attention to Os prospects

[blue tiger x]

bonds should be 100 best hr hitter of all time
arod

[scrimpandsave]

A Rod 97

Miguel Cabrera

[jmillhimes]

Cabrera- 89


Roy oswalt

[scrimpandsave]

Oswalt 91

Randy Johnson

[sfochs12]

when are we going to get the actuall ratings?
Johnson: 87???
Corey Hart

[tastelikechkn]

84

Justin Upton

[Wookie481512]

Justin Upton - 84

milton Bradley (ChC and back in the NL)

Adrian Gonzalez

[scrimpandsave]

González 86

Chipper Jones

[falcgun1337_Xbox360]

Adrian Gonzalez 92 IMO

Chipper Jones 91

Gary Sheffield

[RAINMAN678]

quentin 88