Who would win in a fist fight?

[YankeeH8TR]

Just for kicks I have a list of the top ten fights I would love to see between major league ball players...Who do you guys think would win?

10. Don Zimmer vs Pedro Martinez
09. David Ortiz vs Ryan Howard
08. Mike Piazza vs Roger Clemens
07. Carl Everett vs Vladamir Guerrero
06. Alex Rodriguez vs Albert Pujols
05. Chaun Figgins vs David Ecstein
04. Manny Ramirez vs Carlos Lee
03. Randy Johnson vs Richie ***son
02. Ichiro vs Hideki Matsui
01. Gary Sheffield vs Barry Bonds

Yea...I'm bored.

[xxpujols4mvpxx]

that is funny, but i won't complain this time because i do the same thing. LOL.
and the winner is.............



10 Don Zimmer LOL
9 Ryan howard
8 Mike Piazza
7 Carl Everett
6 Albert Pujols
5 chone figgins
4 MANNY RAMIREZ
3 Richie ***son
2 hedeki matsui
1 Gary Sheffield


what about CC sabathia v.s. Bob Wickman?

[YankeeH8TR]

I think Bob is tougher than CC but i would have to disagree with number 7 and number 8 and I think Randy Johnson would win in a split decision over Richie

[xxpujols4mvpxx]

i feel ya............ Vladdy could whoop Carl Everett.

[MajorLeagueBaseball4ever]

You forgot Kyle Farnsworth

http://sportsmed.starwave.com/media/mlb/2003/0619/photo/a_farnsworth_vi.jpg

[ChunkeyMonkey]

LOL, nice pic. By the way, I think Roger would kick Piazza's ***.

[xxpujols4mvpxx]

This forum is funny as he.ll

[cheatcommandos]

Here's who would win your 10 fights

10. Pedro, in 1 punch.
9. Ryan Howard (Papi doesn't usually fight, he's a gentle giant, so Howard probably gets the advantage)
8. Piazza would be more motivated, but Clemens wins
7. Vlad is too quiet to fight, so Crazy Carl (of your Seattle Mariners, unfortunately) wins by default
6. I don't trust A-Rod in a fight after Varitek blasted his face, but at the same time, Pujols isn't much of a fighter. So this one ends in a draw.
5. This depends, whose feet are quicker so they can dance away from another person's punches (ala Muhammed Ali), maybe Figgins, but tough to say.
4. Manny would hide behind a wall and he'd overreact to the simplest of jabs (like he did when Clemens threw up and in against him in the '03 ALCS) so I'd give it to Lee as long as he had one good punch in him
3. Hmmmmmmmmmmmm, this is a toughie, I'll give it to Richie, but the fight would go the 12 round distance.
2. I'd say Ichiro as long as he could get in one good punch and used a "rope a dope" type strategy against Matsui
1. NO ONE! Because both are disqualified for taking 'roids!

THANKS FOR PLAYING! HAVE A NICE DAY!

[MajorLeagueBaseball4ever]

"Papi doesn't usually fight, he's a gentle giant, so Howard probably gets the advantage"

Actually, he tried to take down on a Tampa Bay pitcher back in last April, and he got ejected while he was yelling at umpire once

[YankeeH8TR]

As for number 10...I think Pedro is big ***** and in a fight man to man I think Zimmer would slap him around. Do we remember what Gerald Williams did to Pedro? He knocked Pedro out with one punch in that Devil Ray brawl, the same in which Big Papi took out that catcher.